If your Honor Rank or badge is not increasing when you received the same Honor as another player it's because not all Honor is equal.
The Honor you receive from other players is not designed to be weighted equally or have equal value. For example, if you receive 10 honor, and another player receives 10 honor, one might go up a rank while the other does not - depending on the context of how the Honor was received.
It's influenced by many things, including who gave the honor, what it is for, and when it was received. In order to discourage "min-maxing" the system and encourage positive behaviors amongst the community, we can't provide exact details on how this system works!
Increasing your Honor
One thing is certain: if you're a good citizen, play well with others in and out of your guild, and keep fresh and fun PvP teams on defense, your honor will eventually go up! For more information on Honor, go here.